Author bio: Alex Shakhov is the founder and CEO of SH Consulting, an email deliverability and security consulting firm. He and his team help companies get delisted from blocklists like SURBL and Spamhaus, fix inbox placement, and design email infrastructure. His security research has been covered by Ars Technica and EdScoop.
I run SH Consulting, an email deliverability and security consultancy. Companies often come to us with issues related to SURBL listings. Most people who call us find out about SURBL issues the same way: A customer says "I never got your email", so someone runs the domain through a blacklist checker, and they find that every line is green except one. Understandably, they often start switching to a different sending tool. However, this never solves the problem, and I’ll tell you why.
What SURBL and URIBL are
The best-known blocklists track who sends a message: the sending IP address or the sending domain. Spamhaus is the biggest of these, and it runs several separate lists – here’s our guide to its lists and return codes. But SURBL and URIBL track what is inside the message: the link to your website, the domain in your signature, the booking link, the logo URL, etc. They are two separate lists run by different operators, but they work the same way, and everything below applies to both. A spam filter that subscribes to these blocklists looks at every domain in the email body and checks it against the blocklist. If your domain is listed, the message gets blocked or marked as spam, regardless of who sent it and from which IP.
This means that changing the ESP or moving to another IP doesn’t help.
Another popular workaround that protects the primary domain is to set up a separate lookalike domain for outreach. This worked until recently, but since April 2026, we are seeing that the main domain gets listed anyway, because it is the one being advertised in the email, even when the mail goes out from somewhere else.
These blocklist issues aren’t limited to outbound mail. We’ve seen replies from clients’ customers bounce, because the reply quotes the listed domain. Moreover, all our clients listed on SURBL also found that their links on LinkedIn were wrapped with a "suspicious page" warning, since LinkedIn refers to SURBL to verify a company’s legitimacy.
How domains end up there
These lists draw on several sources, including phishing and malware feeds. There are three ways for a legitimate business to end up on these lists: Somebody reports your email by hand, your mail lands in spam traps, or your domain is being spoofed because your DNS records do not include DMARC p=reject.
Spoofing is fixed with DMARC enforcement, not with verification, and since traps are what we see most often, the rest of this article will focus on traps.
When you create a ticket with SURBL, you won’t get much detail from them. They aren’t going to tell you which address hit the trap, because then the trap would stop working.
What we see over and over again in these cases is that traps come from the mailing lists. They come in with bought or scraped data, with old contacts nobody has emailed in years, and with typos made at signup or during data entry. Authentication, DMARC p=reject, content, and warm-up all matter, but none of them puts a trap in your database.
Where spam traps come from
Pristine traps are addresses that never belonged to a person. They are published in places only a scraper would read, so they end up in scraped and purchased lists, and in whatever data vendor bought from the scraper.
Recycled traps were once real mailboxes. Typically, the person in charge of the mailbox left the organization, the mailbox was closed and bounced for a while, and then it was later switched back on to see who is still mailing it. These live in old segments: the 2019 webinar list, the CRM export from several years ago, the event contacts nobody touched since, etc.
Typo traps sit on misspelled domains. Some are misspellings of the big mailbox providers, while the particularly clever ones are misspellings of ordinary companies. A B2B services firm we worked with hit traps on domains made to look like companies they actually did business with. In another database, we found four leads at the same company for which the website field was spelled correctly, but where all four email addresses were missing one letter in the domain. Typo traps come in through signup forms, manual entry, and enrichment tools that guess an address from a name and a company.
What verification catches before you send
A verification pass will not show you a list of traps. Anyone promising to use a verification pass to remove every trap from your list is lying. What it does is remove the kinds of addresses traps are made from, and the kinds of lists they hide in.
- Dead mailboxes. An address that hard-bounces today is a candidate for a recycled trap later. Dropping it now means you are not still mailing it when it comes back to life.
- Domains with no MX record. Nobody receives mail there. If such domains are in your list at all, it tells you something about where that list came from.
- Typo domains. The misspelled versions of real providers and real companies, which is where typo traps live.
- Disposable addresses. Throwaway inboxes used to get past a form, which mean no future engagement and indicate that your form needs work.
- Catch-all results. The domain accepts mail for any address, so nobody can confirm the mailbox exists. A lot of real companies are configured this way, as are a lot of trap domains.
Verification tells you whether an address can receive mail. It doesn’t tell you whether you should send to it, because a trap is a working mailbox. Fortunately, there is a second kind of check for this issue: Bouncer’s Toxicity Check scores each address from 1 to 5 based on the likelihood that it is a potential spam trap, a known complainer or a widely circulated address. It won’t name the traps (which nobody can accurately do), but it tells you which part of the list to leave out.
Cold outreach
Cold senders get hit the most, and it isn’t about volume. One company that came to us was sending 300 to 400 cold emails a week and still got listed.
It’s simple: The addresses come from data tools and scraping, so the sender has never received a reply or a click from any of them. Every address gets a sequence of four or five emails. There is often no unsubscribe link. Nobody removes a contact for unresponsiveness, and there’s no proper lead sunsetting policy in place, because almost everyone is unresponsive in cold outreach.
Luke Martinez, who runs deliverability at SH Consulting, compares traps to radiation: A small dose over a long time does the same harm as a big dose all at once. One accidental email to a typo domain is forgiven, because typos happen; the same sales pitch arriving at the same trap twice a month for a year is not forgiven.
This is why verification should happen before every campaign and not just once a year. B2B contact data goes stale fast! People change jobs, mailboxes get closed, and companies get bought. A list verified in January might be a completely different list in June. And since AI tools have made it cheap and easy to build a list and launch a sequence, the listings we work on suggest much less tolerance for this kind of mail than there was a year ago.
There is now even a separate blocklist for it: Validity’s Heatwave, which targets domains used for cold email and automated warm-up.
What to do with the results
As much as possible, aim to only send messages to addresses that come back deliverable, on domains that match the company you meant to reach.
Hold catch-all and unknown results. Nobody can confirm those mailboxes, so don’t treat them as a yes. For cold outreach, leave them out entirely. For your own customers and opt-ins, send only if you have evidence the person exists: a reply, a purchase, a login, a recent open, etc.
Drop undeliverable, no-MX, disposable, and typo results, then put them on a suppression list. Putting them on a suppression list is more important than deleting them, because otherwise the same address will come back in the next import.
A short routine to follow
- Verify at signup. Check the address in the form while the person is still on the page and can fix the typo.
- Re-verify old segments. Check any address that hasn’t been mailed in six months before sending anything.
- Verify any list before its first send. Whether it’s event attendees, a partner’s list, an enrichment export, or a batch from an outreach tool, check it before you mail it. The first send to unverified data is where most listings start.
- Stop mailing people who never respond. A pristine trap — or a recycled one that has been switched back on — will come back as deliverable, so verification alone won’t find it. What a trap never does is reply or buy. Decide how many unanswered emails a contact gets, and stop sending after you reach that point.
What to do if you’re already listed
First, clean the list. Delisting requests are taken seriously when you can say what you found, what you removed, and what you changed in your process so it won’t happen again. A request that only says "please remove us" usually doesn’t go anywhere.
If you’re currently listed and can’t work out why, this is what we do: SURBL delisting at SH Consulting.

